I don't bind keys, so no chance of that. I just installed 24.2 and let it copy my config from 24.1, which still works as it should. Definitely a 24.2 problems, whether it lost something or didn't copy something.
OK, I just unbound pad enter from everything and now it's back to the original issue: inserts a line and only indents as far as the 'if' in my example above. Or the start column of the previous line. That is, it's ignoring the beautifier settings. Enter works as expected.